Koinonia House Online   “Bringing the world into focus
through the lens of Scripture”
Home > Technical > Physics > Was Einstein Wrong? First Time Here?  

Physics Update:

Was Einstein Wrong?

by Chuck Missler




One hundred years ago, Albert Einstein published a series of papers that would transform the way we see the universe. Scientists call 1905 Albert Einstein's annus mirabilis, or year of wonders. Today, the world is celebrating the centennial anniversary of those revelations, which included Einstein's theory of special relativity and the famous equation E=mc. In honor of Einstein's work, the United Nations has declared 2005 to be the World Year of Physics.

Einstein's theory of relativity resulted in significant scientific and technological advances. The mathematical formalism of relativity based on the universal constancy of the speed of light intermingled space and time into a four-dimensional continuum. His ground-breaking work provided the foundation for modern physics and revolutionized what scientists believe about space, time, light, and matter.

Physics2005 Conference

Dr. Michael Murphy, a Research Associate at the Institute of Astronomy in the University of Cambridge and a Research Fellow of Darwin College in Cambridge, recently spoke on the topic of physical constants at the Physics2005 Conference held at Warwick University.

Physical constants, such as the speed of light in a vacuum, are one of the cornerstones of modern physics. However, for the past five years Dr. Murphy and his colleagues have been studying possible variations in the fundamental constants of nature. His research, which has been described as the most detailed survey ever performed, suggests that some of the physical constants could be changing.

"We are claiming something extraordinary here," said Dr. Murphy, "The findings suggest there is a more fundamental theory of the way that light and matter interact; and that special relativity, at its foundation, is actually wrong. It could turn out that special relativity is a very good approximation, but it's missing a little bit. That little bit may be the doorknob to a whole new universe and a whole new set of fundamental laws."

Dr. Murphy used the largest optical telescope in the world, the Keck telescope on Mauna Kea in Hawaii, to study light from distant quasars. The data he collected suggests that the "fine structure constant" may be changing over time.

The fine structure constant governs the electromagnetic force which holds all atoms and molecules together. The speed of light depends on the fine structure constant. If the fine structure constant actually varies with time, then the speed of light probably does as well.

Measuring the Speed of Light

Throughout history our knowledge of how light travels has changed. Greek philosophers generally followed Aristotle's belief that the speed of light was infinite. Even Johannes Kepler (1571-1630), the German astronomer and mathematician best known for his laws of planetary motion, maintained the majority view that light was instantaneous. Rene Descartes (1596-1650), famous for his work in both philosophy and mathematics, also believed in the instantaneous propagation of light.

It wasn't until 1677 that a Danish astronomer named Olaf Roemer announced that the anomalous behavior of the eclipse times of Jupiter's inner moon could be accounted for by a finite speed of light. It took another half century for that notion to be accepted. It wasn't until 1729 that James Bradley's independent confirmation finally ended the opposition to a finite value for the speed of light. Roemer's work, which had split the scientific community for 53 years, was finally vindicated.

The velocity of light is widely regarded as the inviolate constant which affects all things: from our knowledge of astronomy to the behavior of subatomic particles. The assumption that the speed of light is constant is at the foundation of modern physics. Physicists have what is called a "standard model" of the universe which allows them to explain all observed phenomena. This standard model cannot explain variations in the constants and so, if these theories are correct, the standard model would need a complete overhaul.

Was Einstein Wrong?

So is it possible that Einstein was wrong? Could it be that the speed of light is not constant? The speed of light has been measured more than 163 times by 16 different methods over the past 300 years. By reexamining the known experimental measurements to date, a handful of scientists have concluded that the speed of light is in fact slowing down.

Barry Setterfield and Trevor Norman were among the first scientists to examine this possibility, and their findings have been reported in this news journal since 1993. Their theories have interesting implications for cosmology"the metaphysical study of the origin and nature of the universe.

If scientists such as Barry Setterfield are correct, and the speed of light has been slowing down, it might indicate that the age of the universe is much younger than the billions of years required for evolution to take place. Those skeptical of the Biblical account of history have often asked the question: If the universe is between 6,000 and 7,000 years old, how is it that objects millions of light years away can be seen?

The answer to that question could be found by analyzing the decay of the speed of light. Needless to say, this view is highly controversial and the majority of physicists have rejected Setterfield's hypothesis. However, if such a theory were eventually proven correct, it would dramatically alter our concepts of the physical universe. And the remarks of Dr. Michael Murphy last month may be another small step in that direction.

* * *

For further study, please see the following briefing packages: Beyond Time & Space, Beyond Perception, and Genesis & the Big Bang.


Physics and the Bible: Is Empty Space Empty?

Lambert Dolphin

Physics and the Bible: Exploding Planets and Ancient Catastrophes

Lambert Dolphin

Physics and the Bible: When the Universe Became Fuzzy

Lambert Dolphin

Physics and the Bible: The History of Hyperspace

Lambert Dolphin

More Turmoil in Physics: Is Light Slowing Down?

Chuck Missler

The Enigma Deepens: Missing Mass Mystery

Chuck Missler

Physics and the Bible: What Holds the Universe Together?

Lambert Dolphin

Quantum Physics: The Boundaries of Reality

Chuck Missler

Physics and the Bible: Faster Than The Speed of Light

Lambert Dolphin

Physics and the Bible: What Is Light?

Lambert Dolphin

The Controversy Continues: Speed of Light Slowing Down?

Chuck Missler


The Creator Beyond Time & Space - The Infinite Designer And A Finite Universe


  • What are the implications of the current upheavals in traditional cosmology, astronomy, and physics?
  • What is the significance of the recent discovery that the Universe is finite?
  • As scientists begin to understand the interactions of basic forces, they discover an unending series of incredible interdependencies, delicately balanced.


Stretching The Heavens - The Speed Of Light And The Dilation Of Time

  • Was the universe really created in six days? How do we explain galaxies whose light has traveled toward us for over 100 million years?
  • Is the absolute vacuum of space really empty? Doesn't the Bible indicate that it can be torn, bent, shaken, stretched, split-apart and rolled up like a scroll?
  • Is the velocity of light an absolute constant?

Beyond Perception - Particle Physics And The Boundaries of Reality

  • Hebrew Cabalists theorized 800 years ago that God established the universe with 10 dimensions.
  • Why do scientists now also believe we live in a 10-dimensional universe?
  • Has physics finally reached the very boundaries of reality?

Privacy Policy

Copyright © 1996-2017 by Koinonia House Inc., P.O. Box D, Coeur d’Alene, ID 83816